Minnesota Stars could be casualty of stadium

Vikings stadium rendering

The new Vikings stadium is expected to create about 7,000 jobs and save numerous others, but if Major League Soccer is part of the equation, an existing Minnesota soccer team could feel the sting.

Had the Minnesota State Legislature and the City of Minneapolis shot down the stadium deal that assures the Vikings will stay in Minnesota for the foreseeable future, there would have been a lot of casualties. Numerous individuals and businesses would have suffered had the Vikings pulled up stakes and left Minnesota.

But, with the stadium deal signed, sealed and soon-to-be delivered, there may be a casualty after all – the Minnesota Stars of the North American Soccer League. Unbeknownst to many sports fans, the Stars have been atop the NASL all season, losing for the first time in 11 games with a loss Tuesday night to the San Jose Earthquakes. They are the current king of the hill in the NASL but, given its Tier Two nature in the world of U.S. soccer, if you aren't a Stars fan, you likely don't know they exist.

The Stars have struggled to maintain a franchise, despite their current success. In 2010, the franchise was on the brink of bankruptcy only to be bailed out by the NASL. The league brought in its own people to try to get the franchise healthy enough to sell to a potential buyer, but one of the selling points extolled by the Wilf family and stadium advocates was that they would have a five-year exclusive right to bring a Major League Soccer (MLS) franchise to the new stadium. Given the 2016 projection for the new stadium, the Vikings would retain MLS franchise rights until 2021.

When soccer enjoyed its greatest success in the United States in the late 1970s, it was the NASL that was the king. However, while still in operation, NASL is viewed by soccer aficionados as the minor leagues of soccer. It has been surpassed in fan interest and media exposure greatly by MLS.

MLS is unique in sports in terms of ownership and the division of power among its member teams. Created in 1993 as part of a U.S. push to host the World Cup in 1994, MLS, which began play in 1996, is a single league entity, not run on an individual franchise basis. The league owns all the teams and it is operated by a collection of investors. Each franchise has an owner/operator that is a shareholder in the league as a whole. The league runs an annual schedule from March to December and currently has 19 teams. MLS has been very open to expansion, adding a Seattle franchise in 2009, a Philadelphia team in 2010, teams representing Portland and Vancouver in 2011 and a Montreal franchise this year.

Given that MLS is more profitable and gets much more media attention (some would argue force-fed media attention to a largely apathetic American fan base in comparison to other major professional sports), the stadium deal and the ability for the Wilfs to try to pull an MLS franchise into a market that already has a NASL franchise could end up being collateral damage in the stadium debate.

For all the jobs that were saved and/or created by the Vikings staying, getting a stadium may well be the death knell for the Minnesota Stars.


  • Receiver Percy Harvin has joined the Vikings' organized team activities this week. Harvin sat out the start of OTAs last week while recovering from minor shoulder surgery in April.

  • In the most recent edition of ESPN The Magazine, there is a stand-alone photo of Jared Allen competing in one of the side events at his charity golf tournament. In keeping with the non-traditional theme of his charity, which provides home accessibility for wounded veterans returning from the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, there was a Longest Slide contest on a gigantic Slip-n-Slide setup. The photo shows Allen competing side by side with his pals Johnny Knoxville and Jason "Wee Man" Acuna of Jackass fame. Allen has been buddies with Knoxville and Acuna since he appeared in a segment of the Jackass movie franchise in which he delivers an open-field hit on Knoxville, who is attempting to reach up to catch a pass and leaves himself open for a big hit from Allen.

  • Some teams are taking their OTAs more seriously than others – perhaps too seriously. The NFL announced Tuesday that it has stripped the Seattle Seahawks of two OTA days because the team engaged in live hitting, which is prohibited in OTA sessions.

    John Holler has been writing about the Vikings for more than a decade for Viking Update. Follow Viking Update on Twitter and discuss this topic on our message boards. To become a subscriber to the Viking Update web site or magazine, click here.

  • VikingUpdate.com Recommended Stories